Niteshift

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The U.S. Supreme Court rejected on Tuesday a constitutional challenge to an Alabama law that makes it a crime to sell sex toys.



The high court refused to hear an appeal by a group of individuals who regularly use sexual devices and by two vendors who argued the case raised important issues about the scope of the constitutional right to sexual privacy.


The law prohibited the distribution of "any device designed or marketed as useful primarily for the stimulation of human genital organs." First-time violators can face a fine of up to $10,000 and as much as one year in jail.


The law, adopted in 1998, allowed the sale of ordinary vibrators and body massagers that are not designed or marketed primarily as sexual aids. It exempted sales of sexual devices "for a bona fide medical, scientific, educational, legislative, judicial or law enforcement purpose."


Georgia and Texas are the only other states that restrict the distribution of sexual devices, according to the court record in the case.


Attorneys for the American Civil Liberties Union, representing those who challenged the law, argued that private, consensual sexual conduct among adults is constitutionally protected and beyond the reach of government regulation.


They said the Supreme Court's decision in 2003 striking down a Texas sodomy law also created a fundamental, constitutional due process right to sexual privacy.


"The evidence shows that this case is not about novelty items, naughty toys or obscene matter. It is a case about human sexuality and extremely intimate acts," the attorneys said.


They said Alabama has never explained "why sales of performance enhancing drugs like Viagra, Cialis and Levitra and even ribbed condoms are not similarly prohibited."


The attorneys said the state did not contest the evidence that about 20 percent of all American women use a vibrator and at least 10 percent of sexually active adults use vibrators in their regular sex life.


A federal judge ruled against the state and found a constitutional "right to use sexual devices like ... vibrators, dildos, anal beads and artificial vaginas."


But a U.S. appeals court based in Atlanta upheld the law by a 2-1 vote.


The appeals court said it agreed with Alabama that the law exercised time-honored use of state police power to restrict the sale of sex. It rejected the ACLU's argument that the constitutional right to privacy covered the commercial sale of sex toys.


Alabama Attorney General Troy King opposed the ACLU's appeal.


"This case involves conduct that is both public and commercial -- the sale of sexual devices to the general public in commercial retail shopping centers" and at in-house Tupperware-style parties, he said.


King said the law respected "the distinction between public commercial conduct and purely private behavior." He said, "It ... stays out of people's bedrooms."


The justices rejected the appeal without any comment or recorded dissent.

http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmp...urt_sextoys_dc


Do I even need to give commentary on this?

__________________
A burning desire for social justice is never a substitute for knowing what you're talking about. -Thomas Sowell

Sometimes the light at the end of the tunnel is muzzle flash.

Buzzby

I was surprised to see that the Alabama law was instituted in 1998.

When I read the beginning of the article I assumed that it was a holdover from the 19th century or the 1910s at the latest. All I can say is that variations in American law and culture are so vast that it's hard to believe we live on the same planet much less the same country.

__________________

S2

It was the tupperware style dildo parties that they were targeting-another reason to not live in alabama I suppose.

MickityMike

Are those dishwasher safe? ...Microwavable?

__________________
I'd be delighted to live in a country where happily married gay couples had closets full of assault weapons. - Glenn Reynolds

Niteshift

Are those dishwasher safe?

Usually.

...Microwavable?

A better question is why would you want to?

DonkeyPunch

Mikey doesn't like cold surprises...

__________________
Posting Guidelines

Buzzby

To paraphrase The Beatles: "Happiness is a warm dildo."