A Thought Experiment: What if Social Toking Replaced Drinking? | Marijuana

A Thought Experiment: What if Social Toking Replaced Drinking?


What would our society look like if cannabis replaced alcohol as the socially acceptable means of celebrating, unwinding, and getting loose on the weekends? Let’s have a look at the evidence for this thought experiment.

Alcohol is almost twice as addictive as cannabis, and nicotine is about three times more addictive than cannabis. Cannabis use disorder is a real medical diagnosis: Some individuals use so much cannabis that they develop physical dependence, experience withdrawal symptoms, and use it to the extent that it negatively affects their economic or social well-being. However, only 9 percent of people who’ve ever tried cannabis end up with this diagnosis. Alcohol use disorder is far more prevalent, affecting 15 percent of the population — prior to the initiation of adult-use cannabis laws.

A substance abuse diagnosis has profound effects on individuals and families, but excessive alcohol use doesn’t necessarily require a medical diagnosis, and it has far-reaching societal impacts as well.  In the United States, the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) estimates that the societal cost of excessive drinking in the U.S. is $249 billion per year. The vast majority of these costs come from lost worker productivity in the form of  hangovers. In states with the least restrictive cannabis laws, work absences drop by 13 percent after legalization.

But what about the health risks and benefits?

Alcohol use has many short- and long-term health risks. Some of the more obvious short-term risks are accidents, injuries and involvement in violent crimes. For instance, blood alcohol levels of 0.05 percent increase a person’s risk of being involved in a motor vehicle accident by 575 percent. To date, no correlation has been identified between detectable levels of THC in the bloodstream and vehicle accidents. This does not mean it is safe to drive while high, however. There are also well-established relationships between alcohol use and domestic violence and other violent crimes. These relationships have not been found for cannabis, and in fact, cannabis users experience lower rates of domestic violence.

Long-term alcohol use has profound effects on the human body and psychology. People who use alcohol chronically are more likely to have high blood pressure, heart disease, stroke, liver disease and digestive problems. Regular cannabis users however, have lower rates of diabetes, lower body mass index, and lower rates of fatty liver disease. Alcohol is significantly correlated with several types of cancer, whereas cannabis may actually help to inhibit tumor cells.

One thing alcohol and cannabis have in common, however, is that they both cause memory loss and dysfunction. These effects persist for several weeks after individuals stop using cannabis. For alcohol users however, the negative impact on brain function can persist even after years of abstinence.

These health effects have significant influence on mortality. For example, in the US, in 2014, 30,700 people died from alcohol-induced causes, according to data from the Centers for Disease Control. The lifespan of these individuals was shortened by an average of 30 years. That same year, not a single person died from cannabis.

The good news in all of this is that we’re beginning to see a fundamental shift in our society as a result of incremental cannabis legalization. Researchers at the University of Connecticut and Georgia State have shown that in states with legal cannabis, alcohol sales are down by at least 15 percent. These findings were based on alcohol purchases at grocery, liquor, and other retail locations, but did not include bars.

Speaking of bars: This brings up the single major benefit that alcohol has, compared with cannabis — accessibility. Despite its major negative impacts on health, violence, life expectancy, and productivity, alcohol is available to every adult in every neighborhood in the US. “Getting a drink” is the default option when it comes to many types of social interactions in our culture: first dates, retirement celebrations, and a lot more. Through years of research, I have come to believe that, when used properly, cannabis is the safest intoxicating substance on the planet, yet only 21 percent of US adults have legal access to use it recreationally.

Even in states where cannabis is legal for adult use, there is still a major challenge to overcome: social and public consumption. In the interest of public health, it makes a lot of sense to disallow people from consuming cannabis in public places.

But this creates problems for the millions of tourists flocking to states with legal cannabis markets. If you can’t consume in a hotel room or in public, what are your options? How can people safely, legally, and comfortably consume? These issues could all be overcome by allowing licensed social consumption venues to sell, serve, and provide advice and oversight of the consumption process.

What would our culture look like if people could use cannabis as a context for getting together? Imagine if we could stimulate our appetites with cannabis, rather than a cocktail. How much more healthy, productive, and better off would we be?  What would happen if we replaced the most commonly abused substance on planet Earth with a substance that has comparatively more genuine health benefits?

A mountain of scientific evidence supports the legalization of cannabis for both medical and adult-use. When this happens, and cannabis becomes as acceptable and accessible as alcohol, we are likely to experience a dramatic cultural and health revolution.

About Author

Adie Wilson-Poe, PhD is a faculty member at the Washington University School of Medicine who has spent more than a decade studying the body's endocannabinoid system.


  1. To say “only 9 percent of adults who’ve ever tried cannabis are diagnosed with Cannabis Use Disorder” is a gross exaggeration – a complete lack of understanding of what was just said. 9% of adults who have ever tried cannabis is a HUGE number. Other studies have shown that 9% of “regular cannabis users” can develop Cannabis Use Disorder.

    • Makes total sense, Mike. If someone tried it 30 years ago they cannot have a ‘Use Disorder’; they don’t use it.
      I’ll agree with 9% of regular users developing a disorder.
      Good catch, thanks for the post.

    • “Cannabis Use Disorder” is a bogus condition. – – Since marijuana is not addictive, if anyone has a problem with it, they just stop smoking.

      Further, even it were a real condition, what would be the harm of it – since science and widespread experience have shown marijuana has no significant harms?

      Marijuana is not alcohol. The preponderance of the research shows marijuana consumption is NOT a significant cause of auto accidents. In 2015, the Drug and Alcohol Crash Risk report, produced by the U.S. Department of Transportation’s National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, found that while drunken driving dramatically increased the risk of getting into an accident, there was no evidence that using marijuana heightened that risk.

      In fact, after adjusting for age, gender, race and alcohol use, the report found that drivers who had recently consumed marijuana were no more likely to crash than drivers who were not under the influence of any alcohol or drugs.

      Marijuana – not guilty as charged.

  2. Who cares about being accurate? Smoking herb is so much better for a person than drinking etoh there is little noteworthy comparison. A gross percentage of traffic accidents involve alcohol. Most domestic violence involves alcohol. Sexual abuse in any form usually involves alcohol. Marijuana, if anything, doesn’t make men violent and alcohol does. Almost all hit and run suspects were drinking alcohol when they left the scene. I can go on and on. Who cares about pot use disorder? If these fools want to smoke their brains to oblivion so be it. There is a small minority of stoners that do this and its not killing them.

  3. Joseph S. Crabbe on

    Stop taking the pot you frickin hippies! As someone who never used cannabis much at all in my youth (10ish times), but always found it enjoyable, here’s one for you … I became a heavy drinker and had to stop for a variety of health and mental health issues in my 40s (including anxiety and depression). Once I quit drinking, while my health improved dramatically, I’ve found that an occasional Kush is not only great for relaxation, but has actually improved my struggles with anxiety and depression. In fact, I believe it would go a long way in the treatment of alcoholism and alcohol abuse.

  4. Cannabis is an aid to meditation which also has mental health benefits. In meditation the mind quiets down to silent.

  5. They are now saying that marijuana has benefits for alzheimers and getting people off addictive drugs. CNN special. The only problem is when drug companies screw around with a perfect medicine. Add nothing take out nothing. The most insignificant part of it works as a catalyst making the whole plant work the magic to help, pain spasms mental health even major medical problems. Using it daily I find dosing changes. Depending on my needs. It is amazing I never used it illegally but medically wow.

Leave A Reply